Skip to main content

Is this a php variable variable bug?



Is there a logical explanation to this?







<?php

$$a = 'hello world';

echo $$a; //displays hello world

echo $$aa; //displays hello world

echo $$aaa; //displays hello world

?>







Source: Tips4all

Comments

  1. if you try

    $$a = 'hello world';
    echo $$a; //displays hello world
    echo $$aa; //displays hello world
    echo $$aaa; //displays hello world


    die( "<pre>" . print_r( get_defined_vars(), true ) . "</pre>" );


    You can see that it has registed a variable with no name so yes, according to PHP's naming conventions, this would be a bug

    ReplyDelete
  2. When doing

    $$a = 'foo';


    you are saying take the value of $a. Convert it to string. Use the String as variable name to assign 'foo' to it. Since $a is undefined and returns NULL, which when typecasted to String is '', you are assigning the variable ${''};

    echo ${''}; // 'foo'


    Ironically, you can do

    ${''} = 'foo'; /* but not */ $ = 'foo';


    And you can do

    ${''} = function() { return func_get_arg(0); };
    echo ${''}('Hello World');
    // or
    echo $$x('Hello World');


    which would trigger a notice about $x being undefined but output Hello World then. Funny enough, the following doesnt work:

    ${''} = function() { return func_get_arg(0); };
    echo $x('Hello World');


    Because it triggers Fatal error: Function name must be a string. Quirky :D

    Since the PHP manual says


    Variable names follow the same rules as other labels in PHP. A valid variable name starts with a letter or underscore, followed by any number of letters, numbers, or underscores.


    I'd consider being able to assign an empty named variable a bug indeed.

    There is a somewhat related bug filed for this already:


    http://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=39150

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm betting that it's defining the variable as something to the effect of ${''}, or a variable with no name, or something along those lines.

    Since neither $a nor $aa nor $aaa are defined, they all point to the same funky, blank variable name when used in a variable variable context.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well, if $a is empty, then you're setting an empty variable name to = 'hello world'... So then every time you reference that empty variable name, you'll get what's stored there...

    It's just like

    $a = '';
    $$a = 'Foo Bar';
    $b = '';
    echo $$b; //Displays Foo Bar

    ReplyDelete
  5. You are not getting it right, consider this:

    $a = 'hello';
    $hello = "hello again";
    echo $$a;


    Output:

    hello again


    In your case, you have not set the value of following variables, so it outputs the same.

    Explanation:

    When you do $$a, it means:

    $ $a;
    ^ ^
    $ used for php vars means a's value that is hello


    So it becomes:

    $hello


    Whose value is:

    hello again

    ReplyDelete
  6. set $a first, then you don't have to worry about this bug.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Slow Android emulator

I have a 2.67 GHz Celeron processor, 1.21 GB of RAM on a x86 Windows XP Professional machine. My understanding is that the Android emulator should start fairly quickly on such a machine, but for me it does not. I have followed all instructions in setting up the IDE, SDKs, JDKs and such and have had some success in staring the emulator quickly but is very particulary. How can I, if possible, fix this problem?

Java Urban Myths

Along the line of C++ Urban Myths and Perl Myths : What are the Java Urban Myths? That is, the ideas and conceptions about Java that are common but have no actual roots in reality . As a Java programmer, what ideas held by your fellow Java programmers have you had to disprove so often that you've come to believe they all learned at the feet of the same drunk old story-teller? Ideally, you would express these myths in a single sentence, and include an explanation of why they are false.

CCNA 1 Final Exam 2011 latest (hot hot hot)

  Hi! I have been posted content of ccna1 final exam (latest and only question.) I will post the answer and insert image on sunday. If you care, please subscribe your email an become a first person have full test content. Subcribe now  Some question  have not content because this question have images content. So that can you wait for me? SUNDAY 1. A user sees the command prompt: Router(config-if)# . What task can be performed at this mode? Reload the device. Perform basic tests. Configure individual interfaces. Configure individual terminal lines. 2. Refer to the exhibit. Host A attempts to establish a TCP/IP session with host C. During this attempt, a frame was captured with the source MAC address 0050.7320.D632 and the destination MAC address 0030.8517.44C4. The packet inside the captured frame has an IP source address 192.168.7.5, and the destination IP address is 192.168.219.24. At which point in the network was this packet captured? leaving host A leaving ATL leaving...