Skip to main content

JSON left out Infinity and NaN; JSON status in ECMAScript?



Any idea why JSON left out NaN and +/- Infinity? It puts Javascript in the strange situation where objects that would otherwise be serializable, are not, if they contain NaN or +/- infinity values.





Looks like this has been cast in stone: see RFC4627 and ECMA-262 at the top of p. 197:







Finite numbers are stringified as if by String(number). NaN and Infinity regardless of sign are represented as the string null.





Source: Tips4all

Comments

  1. At all "security reason" answerer:
    Security isn't a valid point!
    If someone has access to your global code to to something like

    NaN={valueOf:function(){ do evil }};


    then he could also do things like

    JSON.parse = function(){ do evil };

    ReplyDelete
  2. Infinity and NaN aren't keywords or anything special, they are just properties on the global object (as is undefined) and as such can be changed. It's for that reason JSON doesn't include them in the spec -- in essence any true JSON string should have the same result in EcmaScript if you do eval(jsonString) or JSON.parse(jsonString).

    If it were allowed then someone could inject code akin to

    NaN={valueOf:function(){ do evil }};
    Infinity={valueOf:function(){ do evil }};


    into a forum (or whatever) and then any json usage on that site could be compromised.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Could you adapt the null object pattern, and in your json represent such values as

    myNum:{
    isNaN:false,
    isInfinity:true
    }


    Then when checking, you can check for the type

    if (typeof(myObj.myNum) == 'number') {/* do this */}
    else if (myObj.isNaN) {/* do that*/}
    else if (myObj.isInfinity) {/* Do another thing */}


    I know in Java you can override serialization methods in order to implement such a thing. Not sure where your serializing from, so I can't give details on how to implement it in the serialization methods.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Could it be because JSON is intended to be a data interchange format that can be used in a variety of platforms and allowing NaN/Infinity would make it less portable?

    ReplyDelete
  5. On the original question: I agree with user "cbare" in that this is an unfortunate omission in JSON. IEEE754 defines these as three special values of a floating point number. So JSON cannot fully represent IEEE754 floating point numbers. It is in fact even worse, since JSON as defined in ECMA262 5.1 does not even define whether its numbers are based on IEEE754. Since the design flow described for the stringify() function in ECMA262 does mention the three special IEEE values, one can suspect that the intention was in fact to support IEEE754 floating point numbers.

    As one other data point, unrelated to the question: XML datatypes xs:float and xs:double do state that they are based on IEEE754 floating point numbers, and they do support the representation of these three special values (See W3C XSD 1.0 Part 2, Datatypes).

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you have access to the serialization code you might represent Infinity as 1.0e+1024. The exponent is too large to represent in a double and when deserialized this is represented as Infinity. Works on webkit, unsure about other json parsers!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

[韓日関係] 首相含む大幅な内閣改造の可能性…早ければ来月10日ごろ=韓国

div not scrolling properly with slimScroll plugin

I am using the slimScroll plugin for jQuery by Piotr Rochala Which is a great plugin for nice scrollbars on most browsers but I am stuck because I am using it for a chat box and whenever the user appends new text to the boxit does scroll using the .scrollTop() method however the plugin's scrollbar doesnt scroll with it and when the user wants to look though the chat history it will start scrolling from near the top. I have made a quick demo of my situation http://jsfiddle.net/DY9CT/2/ Does anyone know how to solve this problem?

Why does this javascript based printing cause Safari to refresh the page?

The page I am working on has a javascript function executed to print parts of the page. For some reason, printing in Safari, causes the window to somehow update. I say somehow, because it does not really refresh as in reload the page, but rather it starts the "rendering" of the page from start, i.e. scroll to top, flash animations start from 0, and so forth. The effect is reproduced by this fiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/fYmnB/ Clicking the print button and finishing or cancelling a print in Safari causes the screen to "go white" for a sec, which in my real website manifests itself as something "like" a reload. While running print button with, let's say, Firefox, just opens and closes the print dialogue without affecting the fiddle page in any way. Is there something with my way of calling the browsers print method that causes this, or how can it be explained - and preferably, avoided? P.S.: On my real site the same occurs with Chrome. In the ex